Skip to main content

Why three-parent babies are the way forward


Scientists are claiming a new IVF technique is three times more successful.












Three-parent babies will likely spark concerns over the creation of 'designer babies'. But Michael Rimington, a practising infertility specialist, explains that while there is DNA from three people in the child, the genetic characteristics of the baby are those of the natural mother and father.

The news that Britain could become the first country in the world tocreate babies with the DNA of three people is incredible. Professor Doug Turnbull and his colleagues at Newcastle University, who have been pioneering this technique, have done some brilliant work and should be congratulated.
We knew there was a chance we could have 'three-parent babies' a few years back, but to see it actually come to fruition (if the proposals pass a public consultation) is stunning.
What this means is that mothers who would otherwise be likely to have unhealthy babies with severe disabilities can instead give birth to healthy babies.
What it does not mean is that this is the start of so-called 'designer babies'. Anyone who says so does not fully understand the technology. There is no way that this technique can influence the eye colour, hair colour or any other external characteristic or make-up of the baby beyond what the mother and father's DNA would do on their own.
The technique simply provides a host egg to contain the genetic material from the mother's egg, either before or after fertilisation by the father. The host egg really is just that – a host – because its nucleus – the part that determines the genetic make-up of a human being – would be entirely removed before the procedure took place. The host egg no longer contains its own nuclear DNA. What you're left with is an empty, functioning 'shell', which will be filled with the mother's genetic material.
Some people view the technique as controversial because it involves 'germ line' modification of the embryo's DNA. This means some mitochondrial DNA will be passed on from the third party to the child, and to future generations as well.
But this is healthy mitochondrial DNA that will simply replace the unhealthy mitochondrial DNA that would have caused health problems for the baby. Health problems that in some cases can be fatal. This is NOT the nuclear DNA – i.e. no DNA that actually influences the child's genetic exterior make-up will be passed on.
So yes, there is DNA from three people in the child, but the genetic characteristics of the child are those of the natural mother and father.
I like to explain it using the example of a laptop with a dying battery. You may replace the battery but where does the energy actually come from?
The emotional stress of caring for and then losing much-wanted children cannot be trivialised. Our moral arbiters would have you believe the scientific community has been sliding down the slippery slope of moral decline for many years, when in reality it is they who are out of touch with society’s aspirations and hopes.
This pioneering work to prevent potentially fatal disease and to give couples an opportunity to have healthy babies is to be applauded.
Although more detailed regulation is required, following public consultation, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority broadly supports this work and rightly so. There is no reason to think this new technique is not safe. It is, however, as always, incumbent upon all involved to ensure the treatment is safe for all parties involved, primarily the children.
Mr Rimington gained his accreditation as a consultant obstetrician & gynaecologist in 1997 then quickly entered full time private practice as an infertility specialist. His area of special interest is the management of women with polycystic ovarian disease, on which subject he has published widely. In 2004 he joined with Mark Wilcox to form the South East Fertility Clinic and set up a new assisted conception service in Tunbridge Wells. He is the designated Person Responsible for the unit as registered with the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Where the Swastika Was Found 12,000 Years Before Hitler Made Us Uncomfortable About I

Minoan pottery from Crete. The Minoan civilization flourished from 3,000 to 1,100 B.C. (Agon S. Buchholz/Wikimedia Commons) ) Swastika from a 2nd century A.D. Roman mosaic. (Maciej Szczepańczyk/Wikimedia Commons A srivatsa (swastika) sign at Nata-dera Temple, Japan. (Cindy Drukier/Epoch Times) From the Sican/Lambayeque civilization in Peru, which flourished 750 to 1375 A.D. (Wikimedia Commons) Ancient Macedonian helmet with swastika marks, 350-325 B.C., found at Herculanum. (Cabinet des Medailles, Paris/Wikimedia Commons) A Buddha statue on Lantau Island, Hong Kong with a swastika symbol on the chest. (Shutterstock*) A 3,000-year-old necklace found in the Rasht Province of Iran. (Wikimedia Commons) The aviator Matilde Moisant(1878-1964) wearing a swastika medallion in 1912; the symbol was popular as a good luck charm with early aviators. (Wikimedia Commons) A mandala-like swastika, composed of Hebrew letters and surrounded by a circle and a mystica...

There’s a Previously Undiscovered Organ in Your Body, And It Could Explain How Cancer Spreads

Ever heard of the interstitium? No? That’s OK, you’re not alone  —  scientists hadn’t either. Until recently. And, hey, guess what  —  you’ve got one! The interstitium is your newest organ. Scientists identified it for the first time because they are better able to observe living tissues at a microscopic scale, according to a recent study published  in  Scientific Reports , Scientists had long believed that connective tissue surrounding our organs was a thick, compact layer. That’s what they saw when they looked at it in the lab, outside the body, at least. But in a routine endoscopy (exploration of the gastrointestinal tract), a micro camera revealed something unexpected: When observed in a living body, the connective tissue turned out to be “an open, fluid-filled space supported by a lattice made of thick collagen bundles,” pathologist and study author Neil Theise  told  Research Gate . This network of channels is present throughout ...

FYI: What Would Happen If Every Element On The Periodic Table Came Into Contact Simultaneously?

There are two ways to go about testing this, neither of which are practical. One requires the energy of dozens of Large Hadron Colliders. The other could yield a cauldron-full of flaming plutonium. Both, however, would probably create carbon monoxide and a pile of rust and salts rather than a cool Frankenstein element. If you toss single atoms of each element into a box, they won't form a super-molecule containing one of everything, explains Mark Tuckerman, a theoretical chemist at New York University. Atoms consist of a nucleus of neutrons and protons with a set number of electrons zooming around them. Molecules form when atoms' electron orbitals overlap and effectively hold the atoms together. What you get when you mix all your atoms, Tuckerman says, will be influenced by what's close to what. Oxygen, for example, is very reactive, and if it is closest to hydrogen, it will make hydroxide. If it is nearest to carbon, it will make carbon monoxide. "That random ...